Apizza Heaven
A 7.8 beats 56% of his scores in the past year (123 reviews). At the same percentile that's a 7.5 in 2019 and a 7.2 in 2017.
Hot out of the ovenLatest 10 reviews
Randy's Wooster Street Pizza
A 8.1 beats 78% of his scores in the past year (122 reviews). At the same percentile that's a 8.1 in 2019 and a 8.1 in 2017.
Mulberry Street Pizza
A 8.2 beats 88% of his scores in the past year (121 reviews). At the same percentile that's a 8.2 in 2019 and a 8.3 in 2017.
Joseph's Pizza Parlor
A 8.1 beats 80% of his scores in the past year (123 reviews). At the same percentile that's a 8.1 in 2019 and a 8.1 in 2017.
Mama Russo's Pizzeria
A 7.9 beats 67% of his scores in the past year (123 reviews). At the same percentile that's a 7.6 in 2019 and a 7.8 in 2017.
Verona Pizza
A 8.2 beats 89% of his scores in the past year (123 reviews). At the same percentile that's a 8.2 in 2019 and a 8.5 in 2017.
Gervasio's Italian Family Restaurant
A 8.4 beats 97% of his scores in the past year (126 reviews). At the same percentile that's a 9.1 in 2019 and a 9.1 in 2017.
La Villa Pizza
A 7.8 beats 60% of his scores in the past year (126 reviews). At the same percentile that's a 7.5 in 2019 and a 7.4 in 2017.
Mercato Roman Pizza Works
A 7.4 beats 35% of his scores in the past year (128 reviews). At the same percentile that's a 7.2 in 2019 and a 6.8 in 2017.
Luciano's Pizzeria & Baked Goods
A 7.6 beats 52% of his scores in the past year (128 reviews). At the same percentile that's a 7.4 in 2019 and a 7.2 in 2017.
The full menuSearch the index
| Score | Restaurant | Location | Date | Review |
|---|
About the nameWhy Five Bites Deep?
We all know how it's supposed to go: one bite, then the score. But anyone who has watched a pizza review knows the truth. By the time the score comes out, we're usually about five bites deep, and sometimes closer to the whole slice.
Rules are rules. Mostly.
Independently sourced. Every score is checked against a public source, like news coverage, Barstool’s own posts or the video, and linked so you can verify it. We never copy data from the One Bite app or sites built on it.
Slice Score Index is an unofficial fan directory. It is not affiliated with Barstool Sports, Dave Portnoy, or One Bite.