About the nameWhy Five Bites Deep?
We all know the rules, one bite, then the score. But anyone who has watched a pizza review knows the truth. By the time the score comes out, we're usually about five bites deep, and sometimes closer to the whole slice.
Rules are rules. Mostly.
Receipts includedHow scores are sourced
Every score on this site is checked against a public source before it goes in:
- The video itself: public YouTube captions and the original review posts.
- Social media posts from Dave Portnoy and Barstool Sports.
- News coverage that reports the score.
Every entry links to its source so you can check it yourself. When sources disagree, we go with the original video or post. We never copy data from the One Bite app or from sites built on it, and we don't use scraped lists or AI summaries.
Spot a wrong or missing score? Email wickandbutter@gmail.com with a link and we'll fix it.
The menuWhat you'll find here
- Search all reviews: all 1,470 scores, filterable by name, city, state, score and type
- Near Me: the best-rated spots by distance from where you are
- Map: every pizzeria pinned and colored by score
- Best Of: the top-scoring pies in one list
- Rankings: scores ranked by city, state and more
- Road Trip: good stops along a drive
- Compare: two cities or two pizzerias side by side
- State and city leaderboards: how each place stacks up locally
- Recent Reviews: the newest scores first
- Year in Pizza: every year's scores at a glance
- Stats: averages, distributions and fun numbers
- Been There and the Freezer Case: track the places you've eaten, plus a freezer aisle of frozen pizza scores
- Weekly Digest: a weekly email with the newest scores
The fine printUnofficial fan site
Slice Score Index (Five Bites Deep) is an unofficial fan directory. It is not affiliated with, endorsed by, or connected to Barstool Sports or Dave Portnoy. Watch and support the reviews at the original source.