Best pizza in New York, NY: Dave Portnoy's scores

29reviews

7.32average

28%scored 8.0+

9.2best

#	Score	Restaurant	Location	Date	Review
1	9.2	Ceres	New York, NY	2025-05-13	Watch the review ↗
2	9.0	Sauce Restaurant	New York, NY	2019-09-24	See it ↗
3	8.5	The Original Joe's Pizza	New York, NY	2017-11-10	Watch the review ↗
4	8.5	Fermento Pizza NYC	New York, NY	2026-06-30	Watch the review ↗
5	8.2	Funzi's Pizzeria	New York, NY	2023-08-17	Watch the review ↗
6	8.1	Rose's	New York, NY	2017-04-03	Watch the review ↗
7	8.1	Little Charli	New York, NY	2022-09-29	Watch the review ↗
8	8.1	LTD Pizza & Bar	New York, NY	2023-08-21	Watch the review ↗
9	7.9	Parla	New York, NY	2025-12-17	Watch the review ↗
10	7.9	Andrea's Pizza	New York, NY	2026-07-15	Watch the review ↗
11	7.8	Spunto	New York, NY	2022-09-30	Watch the review ↗
12	7.8	Jonny's Pizza	New York, NY	2025-12-15	Watch the review ↗
13	7.5	Vito's Slices & Ices	New York, NY	2019-09-19	See it ↗
14	7.4	Upside Pizza	New York, NY	2019-01-16	See it ↗
15	7.4	Nolita Pizza	New York, NY	2019-09-26	See it ↗
16	7.3	Gigino Trattoria	New York, NY	2019-04-24	See it ↗
17	7.3	Crispiano	New York, NY	2023-06-29	Watch the review ↗
18	7.3	Fiorentina Pizzeria and Grill	New York, NY	2023-10-24	Watch the review ↗
19	7.2	Eleven B	New York, NY	2019-10-17	See it ↗
20	7.1	Traditas Pizza	New York, NY	2023-06-27	Watch the review ↗
21	7.1	Italian Trattoria	New York, NY	2023-07-05	Watch the review ↗
22	7.1	Crispy Heaven	New York, NY	2023-08-22	Watch the review ↗
23	6.7	Andiamo Pizza	New York, NY	2022-09-02	Watch the review ↗
24	6.7	Ledo Pizza	New York, NY	2022-11-25	Watch the review ↗
25	6.6	Uncle Sam's Pizza	New York, NY	2023-06-30	Watch the review ↗
26	6.3	Pizza and Shakes	New York, NY	2023-10-25	Watch the review ↗
27	5.6	Stella 34 Trattoria	New York, NY	2021-05-24	See it ↗
28	4.9	PDA Slice Shop	New York, NY	2023-10-27	Watch the review ↗
29	3.8	Five Boys	New York, NY	2022-10-04	Watch the review ↗

← All cities NY leaderboard Compare this city