Islamorada Pizza Co.

📍 Islamorada, FL

6.8

Stool Presidente’s scoreIslamorada Pizza Co.

Score
6.8 / 10
Location
Islamorada, FL
Date
2025-11-06
See it ↗

9th percentile. A 6.8 beats 9% of his scores in the past year (172 reviews). At the same percentile that's a 6.2 in 2019 and a 5.4 in 2017.

<5: 37 scores<55: 18 scores55.5: 27 scores5.56: 68 scores66.5: 181 scores6.56.87: 396 scores77.5: 448 scores7.58: 181 scores88.5: 34 scores8.59: 12 scores99.5: 2 scores9.5
Where a 6.8 falls among 1404 restaurant scores: it beats 15% of them. Highlighted bar = this score.
Every restaurant score by review date (x) and score (y). The outlined dot is this review. Hover or tap a dot for its name and score.

Find it

📍 84001 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, Florida, 33036 (address from OpenStreetMap)

Get directions (Google Maps) Apple Maps

Where the review is

Score as reported in Dave Portnoy's public review; see the original source for the full review. This is an unofficial directory entry.

← Back to all scores See on map Compare