2026 in Pizza

The year in Stool Presidente’s scores.

2017 · 2018 · 2019 · 2020 · 2021 · 2022 · 2023 · 2024 · 2025 · 2026

99reviews
7.61average
26%scored 8.0+
1in the 9+ club
NYbest state (avg 7.90, 8 reviews)
Octoberbest month (avg 7.96, 11 reviews)

EliteThe 9+ club

  1. 9.1Big Al's PizzaNorth Billerica, MA · 2026-08-26

Cream of the cropTop 10 of 2026

  1. 9.1Big Al's PizzaNorth Billerica, MA · 2026-08-26
  2. 8.5Bucky's PizzaChatham, NJ · 2026-06-17
  3. 8.5Fermento Pizza NYCNew York, NY · 2026-06-30
  4. 8.4Primavera PizzaLivonia, MI · 2026-09-15
  5. 8.4Gervasio's Italian Family RestaurantCrosswicks, NJ · 2026-10-14
  6. 8.3Johnny's PizzaBryn Mawr, PA · 2026-08-20
  7. 8.3Amelia Street Pizza CoHazel Park, MI · 2026-09-22
  8. 8.2Tony's Pizza NapoletanaSan Francisco, CA · 2026-02-17
  9. 8.2Pizza DadaChicago, IL · 2026-04-09
  10. 8.2Nico's Charred PiesCopiague, NY · 2026-04-14

Restaurant reviews only (frozen pies excluded). Best state and best month need at least 5 reviews.